Punditry roles can be a minefield filled with verbal hazards, as one ex-Manchester United player is finding out the hard way
Former Manchester United player Michael Stewart is afraid he may lose his BBC punditry role after finding himself on the wrong side of the Scottish Football Association. Stewart has established a reputation for his cutting â often controversial â comments on BBC Radio Scotland.
The 45-year-old, who started his football career with United, talked himself into a Scottish FA ban after he suggested there was a "cover up" when he accused VAR of releasing two images of an offside incident with two different lines during St Mirren's clash against Hibernian. He was also reprimanded for referring to the Scottish Football Association head of refereeing as "wee" Willie Collum.
These incidents resulted in the Scottish FA banning him from the country's national stadium Hampden Park, resulting in him broadcasting the Scottish Cup semi-final from within a Premier Sports production van parked outside. He was also forbidden from covering Scotland's World Cup send-off friendly against Curacao at Hampden.
FOLLOW OUR MAN UNITED FB PAGE!Latest news and analysis via the MENâs Manchester United Facebook pag
Things don't look to have improved as he was banned from attending a media briefing delivered by Collum on some rule changes.
Speaking to The Times, he admitted there is a nervousness about potentially losing his many media roles if broadcasters feel his recent track record is not worth the risk-to-reward ratio about hiring him. When asked if he felt this was the case, he replied: " Of course you do [think that], constantly.
"At the Scottish Cup semi-finals Premier were openly supportive of me. But of course that is part of it and I am sure that is part of the thought process [from the SFA] as well. That is the argument you have inside your head all the time about certain things.
"A lot of the time people are not comfortable being openly critical. Everyone is different. But it does create a lot of stress personally and [that is] extended to people around me.
"For people you are working with at Premier or the BBC, there are elements of stress for them as well having to deal with a situation which shouldnât really be a situation. And family, mostly, is where the stress comes in.
"But Iâm not the first and I wonât be the last in any walk of life. It is the world we are living in where a lot of the time organisations and authorities do tend to throw their weight about. Itâs not beneficial for me, itâs not beneficial for the authorities, it doesnât really benefit anybody to have this sort of impasse and loggerheads.
"Even when it first happened I had contact from people that are connected within saying, âLetâs try and organise a meeting.â And I was, like, 'Absolutely.â Thatâs what weâre trying to do.
"And I think that thatâs what itâs sort of moving towards. Iâm not wanting to get into a war of words, but equally people need to be able to meet and discuss. I want to be clear that I canât say âOK then, Iâm not going to criticiseâ or âIâm not going to do this or thatâ.â
He also said he would be willing to apologise for some of his comments, particularly when it comes to his 'Wee Collum' quip, even though he "didn't see the problem with it" at the time.
Former Manchester United player Michael Stewart is afraid he may lose his BBC punditry role after finding himself on the wrong side of the Scottish Football Association. Stewart has established a reputation for his cutting â often controversial â comments on BBC Radio Scotland.
The 45-year-old, who started his football career with United, talked himself into a Scottish FA ban after he suggested there was a "cover up" when he accused VAR of releasing two images of an offside incident with two different lines during St Mirren's clash against Hibernian. He was also reprimanded for referring to the Scottish Football Association head of refereeing as "wee" Willie Collum.
These incidents resulted in the Scottish FA banning him from the country's national stadium Hampden Park, resulting in him broadcasting the Scottish Cup semi-final from within a Premier Sports production van parked outside. He was also forbidden from covering Scotland's World Cup send-off friendly against Curacao at Hampden.
FOLLOW OUR MAN UNITED FB PAGE!Latest news and analysis via the MENâs Manchester United Facebook pag
Things don't look to have improved as he was banned from attending a media briefing delivered by Collum on some rule changes.
Speaking to The Times, he admitted there is a nervousness about potentially losing his many media roles if broadcasters feel his recent track record is not worth the risk-to-reward ratio about hiring him. When asked if he felt this was the case, he replied: " Of course you do [think that], constantly.
"At the Scottish Cup semi-finals Premier were openly supportive of me. But of course that is part of it and I am sure that is part of the thought process [from the SFA] as well. That is the argument you have inside your head all the time about certain things.
"A lot of the time people are not comfortable being openly critical. Everyone is different. But it does create a lot of stress personally and [that is] extended to people around me.
"For people you are working with at Premier or the BBC, there are elements of stress for them as well having to deal with a situation which shouldnât really be a situation. And family, mostly, is where the stress comes in.
"But Iâm not the first and I wonât be the last in any walk of life. It is the world we are living in where a lot of the time organisations and authorities do tend to throw their weight about. Itâs not beneficial for me, itâs not beneficial for the authorities, it doesnât really benefit anybody to have this sort of impasse and loggerheads.
"Even when it first happened I had contact from people that are connected within saying, âLetâs try and organise a meeting.â And I was, like, 'Absolutely.â Thatâs what weâre trying to do.
"And I think that thatâs what itâs sort of moving towards. Iâm not wanting to get into a war of words, but equally people need to be able to meet and discuss. I want to be clear that I canât say âOK then, Iâm not going to criticiseâ or âIâm not going to do this or thatâ.â
He also said he would be willing to apologise for some of his comments, particularly when it comes to his 'Wee Collum' quip, even though he "didn't see the problem with it" at the time.
Related Coverage
- Ex-Man Utd star, 45, worried about BBC punditry job after being slapped with ban â The Sun
- The pundit banned by the Scottish FA for calling an official âweeâ â The Times
- Michael Stewart calls on Willie Collum to end feud as he asks for sit down chat â The Scottish Sun'I played for Man Utd - now I'm worried about losing BBC job after controversial comments'
- The Scottish Sun'I played for Man Utd - now I'm worried about losing BBC job after controversial comments' â Daily Express