Uefa plans to commission an independent valuation of Fifaâs World Cup sale plans after concerns that Gianni Infantino agreed to sell the tournamentâs future profits to a private equity firm at below the market rate.
The European governing body is unmoved by the written apology issued by Infantino to Fifaâs 211 member associations on Tuesday after crisis talks in Morocco. It will continue to push for his removal, with its tactics including further scrutiny of a proposal the president belatedly conceded was âa mistakeâ.
The Fifa Forward Enterprise plan that was abandoned last week after four days involved a 21% stake being sold to Thrive Capital for $4.2bn (ÂŁ3.1bn). The US private equity firm is led by Joshua Kushner, the brother of Donald Trumpâs son-in-law Jared Kushner.
Uefa played a key role in Fifaâs U-turn, which was triggered by all 55 member associations threatening to boycott the World Cup and other tournaments, and is now seeking to establish how the $20bn valuation of Fifaâs commercial assets was worked out. Uefa has spoken to several market analysts to seek opinions regarding an independent valuation and a formal study is likely to follow once the storm surrounding Infantinoâs immediate future has passed.
Last week, the Fifa sales deck circulated details that did not contain any information of the valuation process or any evidence of a competitive tender. âWe need to find out if they were selling the World Cup at a knockdown price,â a source with knowledge of Uefaâs plans said. âHow did they get to $20bn? Was it a robust process?â Fifaâs revenues for the four-year cycle that culminated in this summerâs World Cup were $15bn, leading the market analysts to suggest that $20bn was a low valuation, particularly as the proposal did not appear to include any provisions to prevent expansion and the creation of new tournaments.
âThe World Cup is the only genuinely global mass entertainment event so an increase of $5bn on current revenues seems low to me,â the source said. âThis looks like a low-ball offer. The obvious financial upside of further expansion that the investors would demand â more teams, more regular World Cups, more Club World Cups â is not priced in.â
Uefa has also called for a review of Fifaâs governance and threatened it with legal action. Fifa is attempting to put on a united front despite scathing internal criticisms of the sell-off plan from leading figures including the secretary general, Mattias Grafström, the chief operating officer, Kevin Lamour, and ArsĂšne Wenger, head of football development.
Infantino appeared alongside Grafström at a Womenâs Africa Cup of Nations group game between Malawi and Zambia in Morocco on Wednesday after attending crisis talks in Rabat. That was followed by a Fifa statement saying the president retained the âfull supportâ of the organisation.
Such apparent support indicates there will be no further dissent from within Fifa and the push for change will have to come from outside the organisation.
Fifa was approached for comment.
The European governing body is unmoved by the written apology issued by Infantino to Fifaâs 211 member associations on Tuesday after crisis talks in Morocco. It will continue to push for his removal, with its tactics including further scrutiny of a proposal the president belatedly conceded was âa mistakeâ.
The Fifa Forward Enterprise plan that was abandoned last week after four days involved a 21% stake being sold to Thrive Capital for $4.2bn (ÂŁ3.1bn). The US private equity firm is led by Joshua Kushner, the brother of Donald Trumpâs son-in-law Jared Kushner.
Uefa played a key role in Fifaâs U-turn, which was triggered by all 55 member associations threatening to boycott the World Cup and other tournaments, and is now seeking to establish how the $20bn valuation of Fifaâs commercial assets was worked out. Uefa has spoken to several market analysts to seek opinions regarding an independent valuation and a formal study is likely to follow once the storm surrounding Infantinoâs immediate future has passed.
Last week, the Fifa sales deck circulated details that did not contain any information of the valuation process or any evidence of a competitive tender. âWe need to find out if they were selling the World Cup at a knockdown price,â a source with knowledge of Uefaâs plans said. âHow did they get to $20bn? Was it a robust process?â Fifaâs revenues for the four-year cycle that culminated in this summerâs World Cup were $15bn, leading the market analysts to suggest that $20bn was a low valuation, particularly as the proposal did not appear to include any provisions to prevent expansion and the creation of new tournaments.
âThe World Cup is the only genuinely global mass entertainment event so an increase of $5bn on current revenues seems low to me,â the source said. âThis looks like a low-ball offer. The obvious financial upside of further expansion that the investors would demand â more teams, more regular World Cups, more Club World Cups â is not priced in.â
Uefa has also called for a review of Fifaâs governance and threatened it with legal action. Fifa is attempting to put on a united front despite scathing internal criticisms of the sell-off plan from leading figures including the secretary general, Mattias Grafström, the chief operating officer, Kevin Lamour, and ArsĂšne Wenger, head of football development.
Infantino appeared alongside Grafström at a Womenâs Africa Cup of Nations group game between Malawi and Zambia in Morocco on Wednesday after attending crisis talks in Rabat. That was followed by a Fifa statement saying the president retained the âfull supportâ of the organisation.
Such apparent support indicates there will be no further dissent from within Fifa and the push for change will have to come from outside the organisation.
Fifa was approached for comment.
Related Coverage
- Gianni Infantino: Uefa says Fifa's backing of its president 'changes nothing' â BBCGianni Infantino latest: Uefa & Conmebol respond as Fifa senior executives back president
- BBCGianni Infantino latest: Uefa & Conmebol respond as Fifa senior executives back president â BBCGianni Infantino: Players union FIFPRO slams FIFA and 'abuse of presidential power' as UEFA doubles down on boycott
- BBCGianni Infantino: Players union FIFPRO slams FIFA and 'abuse of presidential power' as UEFA doubles down on boycott â skysports.com
- Gianni Infantino refuses to resign but issues apology in last-ditch survival bid â The Times